Save the NRC!
VOTE NO to Prevent the NRC Acquisition by KAB!


Home Page

Open Letter to
NRC Members

Letter from
Cliff Case,
NRC Founder
Aug 3, 2009

Breaking News: Recycling Organizations of North America (RONA)
Aug 3, 2009

Note: We are seeking campaign volunteers in all NRC affiliated states and organizations in addition to pre and post-vote legal support.  To volunteer send a message to:
Volunteer@SaveTheNRC.org

NRC Board Members Explain Their Opposition to KAB's Acquisition of NRC

August 21, 2009

Marjorie Griek
Executive Director
Colorado Association for Recycling

Dear Marjorie:

Thank you for your inquiry about our votes.   The undersigned members of the Board of Directors of the National Recycling Coalition (NRC) voted against the dissolution of NRC primarily for the following reason:  Functionally, NRC will become a wholly-owned subsidiary of Keep America Beautiful (KAB). KAB is not a democratically elected membership organization. It has a Board of Directors that is self-appointed with a mission driven largely by its contributors.  The two organizations, while somewhat similar, have fundamentally different world views of recycling and resource conservation and we believe the NRC would become subservient to the larger corporate perspective of KAB.  Culturally these two organizations are very different. 

Despite the best of well meaning intentions and verbal commitments by the CEO of KAB, we can only go by the term sheet that was presented to us by KAB.   The terms of the agreement we believe will effectively change the historic role that NRC has, and should, play in the future.

If you review the mission statements and guiding principles of the two organizations taken from their websites you can see how they differ

NRC's Mission 
 

NRC’s objective is to eliminate waste and promote sustainable economies through advancing sound management practices for raw materials in North America.  
 

Guiding Principles 

In conjunction with source reduction, reuse, and composting, the recycling of valuable materials is essential to a sustainable environmental, energy, and economic future.  

  • Recycling is resource management, not waste management.

  • Materials recovery is the preferred management option for all residential, commercial, and industrial discards.

Recycling is a shared responsibility and requires citizen engagement.

    • Recycling requires the participation and collaboration of all stakeholders – citizens and consumers, raw materials providers, product manufacturers, product distributors and retailers, providers of recycling infrastructure, and all levels of government.
       

    • Recycling programs must be accessible and convenient for all residential, business and institutional settings.

Recycling goals must be clear, achievable, and measurable.

  • The foundation of successful recycling policy and programs is accurate and unbiased information.

  • Stakeholders should develop a uniform system for measuring discards, recycling and composting, and waste disposal.

  • Stakeholders should establish customized and achievable recycled content goals.

  • Recycling stakeholders must support development and dissemination of sound, scientifically based, and balanced educational material that informs citizens on the need for recycling and re-engages consumers in the recycling process.

Products and packaging must be designed to take into account and address environmental impact.

  • Products must be designed, manufactured, packaged, distributed, managed, and used to optimize the continuing value and recovery of the used materials and minimize the environmental and climate impact throughout the life cycle of the product.
     

  • Manufacturers should develop and support programs that optimize the recovery of post-consumer and post-industrial materials.

  • Product and package environmental claims and labeling programs should be standardized, accurate, enforceable, and useful for consumers.

Successful recycling requires equitable economic policies.

    • The cost and value of recycling, in comparison to alternative management options and waste disposal, must be transparent to consumers and take into account sustainable development measures for resource depreciation (land and natural resources), energy savings, and environmental impact.

  • Government policies and programs for management of discards must not favor virgin materials use and waste disposal over materials management by source reduction, re-use, recycling, and composting.

  • Government tax policies must provide direct and in-direct incentives for recycled materials utilization, new recycling technologies, and infrastructure development.

  • Recycled materials must have access to free and global markets for commodities.

Think globally, act locally.

  • Taking into account regional and local differences, state and local collection policies and programs should utilize practices that optimize participation rates, cost-effectiveness, direct incentives, and energy efficiency.

  • Local governments must have sufficient means, tools, and the necessary authority to implement successful residential, commercial, and institutional recycling programs.

KAB’s Mission 
 

Engaging individuals to take greater responsibility for improving their community environments.  
 
 

Guiding Principles 

As a recognized leader in community improvement, Keep America Beautiful is guided by these principles:  

Education:
 This is the key to encouraging positive behaviors toward community improvement.  
 

Individual Responsibility:
 Improving communities, their environment, and quality of life all begins with personal responsibility -- individuals becoming more engaged as citizens and stewards of the environment. 
 

Public-Private Partnerships:
  Broad-based community alliances are essential to achieve sustainable community improvement.  
 

Volunteer Action:
  By engaging volunteers we extend the reach of our education and multiply the impact of our actions. 
 

Our Focus
Keep America Beautiful changes behaviors and improves communities through a focus on: 
 
 

Litter Prevention: Defining litter, identifying the causes, and reducing it by organizing cleanups, and promoting proper handling of discarded waste in our communities. > Learn More  

Waste Reduction and Recycling:Reducing the impact of solid waste in our communities through integrated programs including responsible consumerism, source reduction and reuse, recycling and education about landfills, composting and waste-to-energy.

Beautification: Improving the visual aspects of our communities through programs that beautify and naturally clean our environment including community gardens, restoring vacant lots, highway and shoreline beautification, urban forests, native and wildflower plantings, and graffiti prevention and abatement.  

 

We do not believe that recovering materials for recycling is only about individual responsibility with the goal of beautification.  It’s about the challenging issues of utilizing scarce local government resources, market development and volatility of commodity prices, the products made from those recovered materials, and finally the demand for those products.  KAB has no historical involvement or interest when it comes to these issues.  In our final analysis, the coalition that makes up the membership of NRC envisions a systemic change to materials management that improves the entire value chain, not just consumer or individual engagement.  Despite our best efforts to get KAB to demonstrate its intentions to incorporate these principles into the agreement or demonstrate their commitment to these principles we were unsuccessful.  For that reason we felt it was our responsibility as board members elected by you the members of NRC to vote against the proposal and support what we believe are the best interests of the members and mission of the National Recycling Coalition. 

You may contact any one of us for further clarification. 

Sincerely, 

Fran McPoland David Refkin  Darryl Young  Joe Van Rossum 

mcpoland@collingswifthynes.com

davidrefkin@gmail.com

dyoung@summitfdn.org

vanrossum@epd.engr.wisc.edu

Download a PDF of This Letter

Do you have something to say on this issue?  If so, Let Your Voice Be Heard!
Sign Our Petition and Add Your Comments!

*Third party statements have not been independently verified.

Send Website Suggestions to: WebAdmin@SaveTheNRC.org


In the Press

74% of Respondents Say NO MERGER!
Waste and Recycling News Poll

Group Fights
KAB-NRC Merger
WasteAge
Jul 13, 2009

KAB Proposes $700K Takeover of NRC
Resource Recycling
June 5, 2009

Key Vote For National Recycling Coalition
BioCycle
July, 2009

Some Urge Vote Against Keep America Beautiful Merger
Plastics News
July 9, 2009